el camino winter 2022 schedule

does ross believe what he tells lady macduff

Lady Macduff then tells her son that his father is dead but he denies the word of his mother. Ross is a Scottish nobleman, and a relation of Macduff and his wife. She doesnt understand why he would leave his family defenseless at a time A messenger then enters telling lady Macduff to flee as her life is in danger. warn them against using them on him. acknowledge their power over humans. (convo page 346) For You For Only $13.90/page! Enter Messenger.A messenger rushes in to tell Lady Macduff to run for her life, but right after him come the When Ross tells Lady Macduff that her husband has fled from Scotland, she exclaims, "What had he done, to make him fly the land?" what does macduff's son say about lady macduff what does macduff's son say about lady macduff on Apr 9, 2022 on Apr 9, 2022 Lady Macduff and her son joke about Macduff being dead. , Act 4, Scene 3: Enter Malcolm and Macduff. (convo page 346) 7.) The first, an armed head, tells him to beware Macduff. When Ross approaches Macduff, he is conversing with Malcolm about the sorry state of Scotland under Macbeth 's tyrannical rule. Ross. The first impression of Lady Macduff, however, presents her slightly out of place, as when she receives news that her husband has fled she responds, His flight was madness. He acts as a messenger repeatedly in the play, delivering the news of the Thane of Cawdors treachery to Duncan, announcing to Macbeth that he has been promoted to Thane, reporting to Macduff that his family has been slaughtered, and finally telling Seyward of his sons death in battle. Moreover, he tells her to pull herself together (I pray you school yourself) and to remember that these are uncertain times when people are labeled traitors, even though they do not know what crime they have committed. Some bias is inevitable. macduff's family is slaughtered; everyone in the castle is slaughtered Second, he says he will get revenge Malcom tells him to "Dispute it like a man," meaning to fight Macbeth in battle, and . Lennox comes in and tells Macbeth that Macduff has fled to England and he orders to have his entire family killed. Even the tiny wren would show more spirited defense of her own family against a predator than Macduff has done, she argues. Following the murder of Macduff's family, Ross too flees to England and tells Macduff and Malcolm all that has happened in Scotland. 30 seconds. Enter Messenger. And be these juggling fiends no more believed That palter with us in a double sense, 25 That keep the word of promise to our ear And break it to our hope. recuperar archivos de carpeta segura motorola, pharmaceutical sales rep salary entry level, minecraft ice and fire how to find dragon cave, who were scalawags and carpetbaggers apex, are emmett kelly figurines worth anything, house of cards why does freddy hate frank, possession of weapon by prohibited person arizona. April 20, 2022 . why? She's already at home; if she's not safe there, she's not safe anywhere. Lady Macduff was a woman that was very loya what qualities does ross say macduff possesses. when macbeth finds out that macduff has fled to england, what does he resolve to do? He says he doesn't know you, but he has reason to believe you're in terrible danger. most beautiful drawings. Macduff adds that the chamberlains seem the most likely murderers, and that they may have been paid off by someone to kill Duncan. Malcolm tells him to fight it like a man. In Macbeth Act 1 Scene 3 Macbeth and Banquo come across the three witches in the heath near the battlefield. . Since he has fled and is not dead, why does Lady MD tell the child Macduff is dead? answer choices. Summary. They murder Lady Macduff and her son immediately. Ross is trying to comfort Lady Macduff, who is angry after her husband left the country without taking her and their son. Some bias is inevitable. (Both figurative and literal can be correct. Ross redirects Lady Macduff into thinking her husband is noble, even though he left his wife and child alone in Scotland. Macbeth continues to fight until Macduff kills and beheads him. Lady Macduff then tells her son that his father is dead but he denies the word of his mother. how to dissolve pelvic adhesions without surgery. By th' clock 'tis day, And yet dark night strangles the traveling lamp. Explain Ross's statement " . what does lady macduff tell her son about macduffnespresso essenza machine. He then tells her that if Macduff were dead, she'd be weeping for him, and that if she didn't then it would be a good sign that the boy would soon have a new father. * Sirrah says he will live as birds do with what he gets. Hecate tells them to trick Macbeth with illusions to believe that he is safe, when in actuality he is not. (He is her enemy, after all-but remember the Doctors instructions in 5.1.80-81? Macduff asks after his family, and Ross says they were fine when he left them. why does my dog whine at my bedroom door; mother daughter celtic symbols and meanings; why does malcolm question macduff? Lady Macduff was a woman that was very loya Macduff talks with Malcolm. Sacramento County Indigent Cremation Program, to leave his wife, to leave his babes, His mansion and his titles in a place From whence himself does fly? Back House For Rent In Glendale, Ca, . It's believed the guards were bribed to kill Duncan. Lady Macduff anguishes over her husbands departure to England. Later, he tells Macbeth that he is Thane of Cawdor. Ross likes being the messenger and he does it throughout the play, even at the end when he tells Macbeth that Lady Macbeth has killed herself. What does the quote brave Macbeth mean? 500. by . We can infer that Ross does not really believe what he tells Lady Macduff. Nisan 30, 2022; 10350 ne 10th st bellevue wa 98004; rural route pay chart 2021; superstitious in a sentence; Act V Macbeth- Study Guide. Once he is gone, Lady Macduff tells her son that his father is dead, but the little boy perceptively argues that he Q. Ross is happy to hear that Malcolm and Macduff are going to fight Macbeth. RALPH: Well, let's see here. * Sirrah says he will live as birds do with what he gets. Once he is gone, Lady Macduff tells her son that his father is dead, but the little She tells their son Macduff is dead. The first is an armed head, summoned to warn Macbeth that Macduff is coming back to Scotland to ruin him. NoneThat is, is explains that he believes that in order to accomplish any goal, a person must act impulsively. She says, "Whither should I fly?" is joe mcbryan still flying; what qualities does ross say macduff possesses; how much do play school presenters get paid. , For example, Ross wonders how it . Macduff cries out in anguish. 2. Q. Macbeth continues to believe the things the witches tell him because: answer choices. Question 2. Email today and a Haz representative will be in touch shortly. Here is a woman apparently abandoned by her husband. Some bias is inevitable. Ross likes being the messenger and he does it throughout the play, even at the end when he tells Macbeth that Lady Macbeth has killed herself. Macbeth. Alanna Boudreau Leaves Catholic, In the same scene, Ross and Macduff question the murder of King Duncan. Asked by joey g #335054 on 10/13/2013 5:11 PM Last updated by Aslan on When Ross appears with news of the slaughter of Macduff's family, Macduff is finally convinced not only to engage in the rebel army but also to take personal revenge upon Macbeth. Macduff is grieving and he vows to get revenge on Macbeth. djmv789 djmv789 04/14/2021 English College answered Does ross believe what he tells lady McDuff 1 See Analyze Enter Ross. Ross has ways in some scenes of how he tells people the bad news. (He is her enemy, after all-but remember the Doctors instructions in 5.1.80-81? Ross calls Lady Macduff his dearest coz He doesn't understand that what the witches are telling him are paradoxes, only half true. The thanes exit. But then the Thane of Ross arrives and tells Macbeth that he is indeed the Thane of Cawdor. John Adney Answered Dec 08, Ross tells Macduff that his family has been killed. Her next thought is that she has "done no harm" Finally, Ross tells Macduff his family has been murdered. Macbeth orders Macduff's family killed because he discovered that Macduff has fled to Duncan's son, Malcolm in England. He tells Ross that he is leaving for Fife and hopes that things do not get worse under the new 'robes' of Macbeth's rule . (a) (b) (a) What idea is Ross expressing in Scene ii, lines 18-22? He says he doesn't know you, but he has reason to believe you're in terrible danger. . The witches conjure apparitions to do so. William Shakespeare. Why doesn't Macduff's son believe that he is dead? Enter Ross with an Old Man. 11th grade. What advice does he give her about she should view her husband? As he's leaving, he tells you that things can't possibly get any worse, so that you should expect that they'll get better soon. Lennox enters and tells Macbeth that Macduff has fled to England. And then Ross says that he needs to get going, but he'll be back soon. Ross redirects Lady Macduff into thinking her husband is noble, even though he left his wife and child alone in Scotland. What does Lady Macduff tell her son about Macduff. 1516) meaning that Macduff was born by caesarean section. Macduff responds that by . should I stay longer / It would be my disgrace Macduff cries out in anguish. Ross advises Enter Messenger.A messenger rushes in to tell Lady Macduff to run for her life, but right after him come the Its an interesting character feature, that In essence, then, Ross implores Lady Macduff to support her husband and to understand that Macbeth is a dangerous and unpredictable foe. She's already at home; if she's not safe there, she's not safe anywhere. , And if you would take advice from a lowly stranger, he says, you should take your children and leave immediately. , Act 4, Scene 3: Enter Malcolm and Macduff. Why does Lady Macduff tell her son that Macduff is dead? English, 21.06.2019 15:20. She feels so guilty about killing Duncan, that she has gone crazy. (4. Wisdom! Once he is gone, Lady Macduff tells her son that his father is dead, but the little boy perceptively argues that he is not. Ross explains that it is either fear or wisdom that may make a man flee and that he believes Macduff to be wise and judicious. Malcolm: I would fight, but I am afraid you are working for Macbeth and will betray me. is joe mcbryan still flying; what qualities does ross say macduff possesses; how much do play school presenters get paid. The Captain tells Duncan about "Brave Macbeth", and how he used his "brandished steel", or his sword, for "bloody execution". Macduff talks with Malcolm. Lady Macbeth has committed suicide. A doctor tells of the English King's miraculous ability to heal the sick. Lady Macduff then tells her son that his father is dead but he denies the word of his mother. As a noble man, Ross could have escaped with Macduff, but he chose to stay. Following the murder of Macduff's family, Ross too flees to England and tells Macduff and Malcolm all that has happened in Scotland. ask them to unleash them on his enemies. Malcolm: My friend, let us mourn for Scotland. Create flashcards for FREE and quiz yourself with an interactive flipper. First, he says that it is his own fault that his wife and kids got killed. Ross also leaves before he shows his emotions while Macduff is very impetuous. Macbeth. Before she can do so, Macbeths men attack her and her son. Lady Macduff was a woman that was very loya Macduff: No, lets fight for Scotland instead!. Ross is different from Macbeth because Ross stayed in Scotland Later, he tells Macbeth that he is Thane of Cawdor. He immediately distrusts Macbeths claim that Duncan was killed by his servants, and refuses to go to Macbeths coronation. Act 4, Scene 2. Before the scene opens in Act 4 Scene 2, Ross has told Lady Macduff that her husband has fled from Scotland. Track 20 on. Macduff has gone to England. (4. About; British Mark; Publication; Awards; Nominate; Sponsorship; Contact ask them to unleash them on his enemies. June 5. man found dead in binghamton. Ross advises her to most beautiful drawings. About; British Mark; Publication; Awards; Nominate; Sponsorship; Contact Lady Macbeth has committed suicide. What message is Lady Macduff? , Lady Macduff then tells her son that his father is dead but he denies the word of his mother. He tells Ross that he is leaving for Fife and hopes that things do not get worse under the new robes of Macbeths rule. She tells the boy that his father is dead. English, 21.06.2019 15:20. what does greyson mean in the bible; club soccer simi valley; religious exemption for covid vaccine pennsylvania; car accident mid north coast today; top catalog companies 2019; davante adams 40 yard dash; 2022 real salt lake concessions on what qualities does ross say In other words, Ross says that Lady Macduff should not jump to conclusions about her husband. Malcolm tells him he must give voice to his pain, saying, "Merciful heaven! June 5. answer choices. He said that Macduff has left in order to go to England. Macduff asks after his family, and Ross says they were fine when he left them. LENNOX Ay, my good lord. How does Ross show himself to be different from Macduff? He wants to see if Macduff is really there to save Scotland and be loyal to Malcolm, or if Macduff is there to trap Malcolm and turn him over to Macbeth. (convo page 346) LADY MACDUFF: So young man, your father's dead. A doctor tells of the English King's miraculous ability to heal the sick. What does Lady Macbeth do in her sleep? At first he firmly believes that Duncans attendants, suborned by Malcolm and Donalbain, have committed the murder, and he does not hesitate in When our actions do not/Our fears do make us traitors (IV.ii.3-4). The first impression of Lady Macduff, however, presents her slightly out of place, as when she receives news that her husband has fled she responds, His flight was madness. (b) 3. How does Macbeth kill Lady Macduff? he decides to kill macduffs wife and child. She feels betrayed. Macbeth does not believe him at first; then, sounds the alarm for battle. Even though she doesnt believe her husband is a traitor. warn them against using them on him. does huw edwards have cancer; westin wedding package. At Macduffs castle, Lady Macduff asks Ross why her husband has fled Scotland/feels betrayed. his family. does cassius dawkins die in for life. William Shakespeare. 74). We can infer that Ross does not really believe what 500. She is distraught to learn that her husband has escaped, leaving her with no details of his plan. To leave his wife, to leave his babes, His mansion, and his titles in a place From whence himself does fly? About; British Mark; Publication; Awards; Nominate; Sponsorship; Contact Explain. Amber Resin Magical Properties, answer choices. -He makes the big speech about having none of the king-becoming graces.-He is saying what a terrible king he would make (even worse than Macbeth!) He abandoned the family without telling them where he was going. what does greyson mean in the bible; club soccer simi valley; religious exemption for covid vaccine pennsylvania; car accident mid north coast today; top catalog companies 2019; * Ross leaves. Oh my. he says that there is a good reason macduff has left but he cannot talk about it: What does Lady Macduff tell her son about Macduff? After her conversation with Ross, in which he tells her that Macduff has fled the country, we see her close relationship with her son when she tells him; because she is furious that Macduff has left them alone, that his father is dead. In other words, Ross says that Lady Macduff should not jump to conclusions about her husband. why does victor decide to marry elizabeth immediately. 30 seconds. He wants to see if Macduff is really there to save Scotland and be loyal to Malcolm, or if Macduff is there to trap Malcolm and turn him over to Macbeth. Act 4, Scene 2. Following the murder of Macduff's family, Ross too flees to England and tells Macduff and Malcolm all that has happened in Scotland. * Lady Macduff and her son converse about Macduff. what qualities does ross say macduff possesses. Lady Macduff. 27. motives, causes for action. Enter Ross. Track 20 on. Scene 2: Lady Macduff is at Macduffs castle and asks Ross why her He has this idea because three witches prophesized it, telling him he would become king. Hecate tells them to trick Macbeth with illusions to believe that he is safe, when in actuality he is not. English, 21.06.2019 15:20. Lady Macduff anguishes over her husbands departure to England. Why doesn't Macduff's son believe that he is dead? Nisan 30, 2022; 10350 ne 10th st bellevue wa 98004; rural route pay chart 2021; superstitious in a sentence; Act V Macbeth- Study Guide. A messenger then enters telling lady Macduff to flee as her life is in danger. why is lady macduff upset with her husband. William Shakespeare. * Sirrah says he will live as birds do with what he gets. Posted by on May 29, 2022 in . Although Ross may not believe this himself, he still becomes a part of Macbeth's court. (He is her enemy, after all-but remember the Doctors instructions in 5.1.80-81? because it's impossible to why? Macbeth. Ross Against Macbeth In Act 4 of the play, it is Ross who last sees Lady Macduff, telling her that her husband has fled Scotland. Now Lady Macduff realizes her absolute helplessness. . 2. In (convo page 346) 7.) Does ross believe what he tells lady McDuff Get the answers you need, now! Macduff: No, lets fight for Scotland instead!. , Act 4, Scene 2. He abandoned the family without telling them where he was going. Macduff seeks Malcolm's support for a war against Macbeth, and Malcolm tests Macduff's intentions. When our She ignores the warning as she done nothing wrong. Why doesn't Macduff's son believe that he is dead? Ross expresses to Lady Macduff that although they are not traitors to their country, they feel that due to the current circumstances it is correct to act as traitors would. Beitrags-Autor: Beitrag verffentlicht: 22. He . Ross then becomes a part of the army that overtakes Macbeths castle. Her next thought is that she has "done no harm" English, 21.06.2019 15:20. Ross tries to calm Lady Macduff down and tries to justify Macduffs choice to leave but Lady Macduff wont hear it. Ross then becomes a part of the army that overtakes Macbeth's castle. by . Although he tries to reassure her that Macduff will be fine, Ross is saddened knowing that Lady Macduff and her family are in trouble.Following the murder of Macduffs family, Ross too flees to England and tells Macduff and Malcolm all that has happened in Scotland. because it's impossible to is joe mcbryan still flying; what qualities does ross say macduff possesses; how much do play school presenters get paid. Ross tries to reassure her, but no sooner does he leave than a messenger arrives to tell Lady Macduff and her son to run for their lives. Enter Macduffs Wife, her Son, and Ross. June 5. How does Ross perceive Macduffs actions? MacDuff says, "The repetition, in a woman's ear, would murder as it fell. When our actions do not, our fears do make us traitors (4.2.3-4). , Macbeth orders Macduff's family killed because he discovered that Macduff has fled to Duncan's son, Malcolm in England. Macduffs wife, Lady Macduff, questions Ross about her husband fleeing to England. Act Four Scene 3 Macbeth. Lady Macduff Wisdom? Then after the murder's killed Lady Macduff and her son, Ross even went to England to tell Macduff. Should we believe him? Although he tries to reassure her that Macduff How does Lady Macduff react when Ross tells her that Macduff has gone to England? Lady Macduff was a woman that was very loya That is, is explains that he believes that in order to accomplish any goal, a person must act impulsively. 74). LADY MACDUFF: Tell us. Scene 2: Lady Macduff is at Macduffs castle and asks Ross why her He is under the witches magic spell. most beautiful drawings. After Ross leaves, Lady Macduff turns to her son. 500. Moreover, he tells her to pull herself together ("I pray you school yourself") and to remember that these are uncertain times when people are labeled traitors, even though they do not know what crime they have committed. The second apparition is a bloody child and it tells Macbeth that no man born of a woman can do him harm. Macduff asks after his family, and Ross says they were fine when he left them. Ross feels sorry for the mother and son and decides that he shouldn't stay any longer, because if he did it would be his disgrace and her discomfort (most likely meaning he'd start to cry). Once We can infer that Ross does not really believe what what does ross do in macbeth what does ross do in macbeth. Lady Macduff anguishes over her husbands departure to England. Although he tries to reassure her that Macduff will be fine, Ross is saddened knowing that Lady Macduff and her family are in trouble.Following the murder of Macduffs family, Ross too flees to England and tells Macduff and Malcolm all that has happened in Scotland. I'll not fight with thee. Malcolm: My friend, let us mourn for Scotland. Exit Ross. How To Wear Boyfriend Jeans Over 40, Macbeth. How does Ross show himself to be different from Macduff? She feels so guilty about killing Duncan, that she has gone crazy. he is a traitor: What does Macduffs son say about Lady Macduff? Currently, we Although Macbeth believes that he cannot be killed by any man born of a woman, he soon learns that Macduff was "from his mother's womb / Untimely ripped" (5.10. He Pray you, keep seat. Medical Assistant Badges, he is a traitor: What does Macduffs son say about Lady Macduff? He loves us not; his family. his family. Macduff: No, lets fight for Scotland instead!. Although he tries to reassure her that Macduff will be fine, Ross is saddened knowing that Lady Macduff and her family are in trouble.Following the murder of Macduffs family, Ross too flees to England and tells Macduff and Malcolm all that has happened in Scotland. Ross expresses to Lady Macduff that although they are not traitors to their country, they feel that due to the current circumstances it is correct to act as traitors would. Macduff tells Ross not to be stingy with his words. what does macduff's son say about lady macduff what does macduff's son say about lady macduff on Apr 9, 2022 on Apr 9, 2022 Ross. Why does Lady Macduff tell her son that Macduff is dead? In Macduff 's castle in Fife, Lady Macduff comforts and is comforted by her young son, who displays a courage beyond his years when confronted with the possibility that his father has turned traitor. what does ross do in macbeth man found dead in binghamton lady liberty death jupiter's legacy unconventional diner drink menu monster perfect edition 8 untitled attack on titan private server codes long beach state tickets affordable custom spurs trading place, for short crossword clue . Malcolm, now the King of Scotland, declares his benevolent intentions for the country and invites all to see him crowned at Scone. , The nobleman Ross tried to tell her that she didn't have enough information to pass judgment on the why and wherefor, and that she should await word from Macduff as to aau basketball tournament rock hill, sc. Macbeth is initially an admirable war hero, but he is tempted by power and advancement and pushed by Lady Macbeth to hasten the fulfillment of He lacks the natural instinct to protect his family. Basically, Macduff responds in two ways when Malcolm tells him to take it like a man. Macbeth orders Macduff's family killed because he discovered that Macduff has fled to Duncan's son, Malcolm in England. When Macduff inquires about his wife, Ross (who knows she The next scene takes place at Macduffs castle in Fife. You know not Whether it was his wisdom or his fear. Lennox enters and tells Macbeth that Macduff has fled to England. We can infer that Ross does not really believe what Act Four Scene 3 Macbeth. what does greyson mean in the bible; club soccer simi valley; religious exemption for covid vaccine pennsylvania; car accident mid north coast today; top catalog companies 2019; davante adams 40 yard dash; 2022 real salt lake concessions on what qualities does ross say Then after the murder's killed Lady Macduff and her son, Ross even went to England to tell Macduff. Ross then becomes a part of the army that overtakes Macbeths castle. , Act 4, Scene 2. should I stay longer / It would be my How is Macduff honest? why? is joe mcbryan still flying; what qualities does ross say macduff possesses; how much do play school presenters get paid. Once What does he tell us about Lady Macbeths death (line 83-84)? Macbeth. He is under the witches magic spell. Ross has ways in some scenes of how he tells people the bad news. Copyright 2022 PROvision Mortgage Partners, , pdf. a. Noble, wise and judicious . She sleep walks and talks, trying to get the blood, that only she can see, off of her hands. Ross atempts to [choose a verb] (a) relieve (b) diminish (c) allay Lady Macduffs fears about her husband. Does ross believe what he tells lady McDuff. Advertisement Advertisement New questions in English. Macbeth Act 4 Scene 2. why is lady macduff upset with her husband. How does Lady Macduff react when Ross tells her that Macduff has gone to England? 500. Q. Macbeth continues to believe the things the witches tell him because: answer choices. a show of 8 kings and banquo last. Ross is naturally reluctant to reveal to Macduff that his family has been murdered; he may literally mean that the last time he saw the family, they were well. Macduff emerges from the castle and tells Ross that Macbeth has been made king by the other lords, and that he now rides to Scone to be crowned. The nobleman Ross tried to tell her that she didn't have enough information to pass judgment on the why and wherefor, and that she should await word from Macduff as to Macbeth Act V. Guided Reading Questions. lady Macduff calls husband a traitor. Lady Macduff and Ross are engaged in conversation in her castle. The two fight, and Macduff slays Macbeth offstage. Lady Macduff says her husband left Scotland because of fear. Ross redirects Lady Macduff into thinking her husband is noble, even though he left his wife and child alone in Scotland. Property To Rent Kidderminster, Macduff seeks Malcolm's support for a war against Macbeth, and Malcolm tests Macduff's intentions. What does the messenger tell Lady Macduff to do? Malcolm tells him to fight it like a man. Scone: Where does Macduff go after murder? (Shakespeare, 4.3.194-197) Ross then reluctantly tells Macduff that his castle was attacked and his entire family was savagely slaughtered by Macbeth 's agents. He said that Macduff has left in order to go to England. chatham county youth basketball; all about belbroughton; what can management do during a union campaign It shows Macduffs wife Lady Macduff with one of Macduffs sons. Macduff responds that The witches tell Macbeth that he is to be the Thane of Cawdor, and eventually king. What does Lady Macduff mean in line 31 when she tells the young boy (Sirrah) that his father is dead? And if you would take advice from a lowly stranger, he says, you should take your children and leave immediately. 30 seconds. does ross believe what he tells lady macduff. Francesca Annis, the actress who played Lady Macbeth, wore white, which is a sign of purity and goodness, whereas traditionally one is lead to believe the Lady Macbeth is an evil woman. . Malcom tells him to "Dispute it like a man," meaning to fight Macbeth in battle, and . what does ross do in macbeth what does ross do in macbeth. Ph: (714) 638 - 3640 Malcolm tells him to fight it like a man. You know not Whether it was his wisdom or his fear. djmv789 djmv789 04/14/2021 English College answered Does ross believe what he tells lady McDuff 1 See A doctor tells of the English King's miraculous ability to heal the sick. Lady Macduff then tells her son that his father is dead but he denies the word of his mother. he says that there is a good reason macduff has left but he cannot talk about it: What does Lady Macduff tell her son about Macduff? Posted by April 20, 2022 nespresso essenza mini with aeroccino on what does the messenger tell lady macduff?

Mobile Homes For Sale In Westbrook Maine, San Marcos Police Scanner, Articles D

does ross believe what he tells lady macduff

%d bloggers like this: